MLB Comparisons

MLB Player Comparisons

Honus Wagner vs Eddie Collins Comparison

by Leave a Comment

Seasons

Check/Uncheck

Honus Wagner

Check/Uncheck

Eddie Collins

 

Info

Teams

Honus Wagner Louisville Colonels (1897–1899), Pittsburg / Pittsburgh Pirates (1900–1917)
Eddie Collins Philadelphia Athletics (1906-1914, 1927-1930), Chicago White Sox (1915-1926)

Position

Honus Wagner Shortstop
Eddie Collins Second Baseman

Height

Honus Wagner 5'11"
Eddie Collins 5'9"

Weight

Honus Wagner 200
Eddie Collins 175

Bats

Honus Wagner Right
Eddie Collins Left

Throws

Honus Wagner Right
Eddie Collins Right

World Series And Playoff Appearances

World Series

Honus Wagner 1 (1909) Star
Eddie Collins 6 (1910-1911, 1913, 1917, 1929-1930) StarStarStarStarStarStar

World Series Appearances

Honus Wagner 2 (1903, 1909) StarStar
Eddie Collins 8 (1910-1911, 1913-1914, 1917, 1919, 1929-1930) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar

Playoff Appearances

Honus Wagner 2 (1903, 1909) StarStar
Eddie Collins 8 (1910-1911, 1913-1914, 1917, 1919, 1929-1930) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar

Awards And Honors

Hall of Fame

Honus Wagner Yes 95.13% in 1936
Eddie Collins Yes 77.74% in 1939

Number Retired

Honus Wagner Yes
Eddie Collins No

MVP

Honus Wagner 0
Eddie Collins 1 (1914) Star

League Batting Champion

Honus Wagner 8 (1900, 1903-1904, 1906-1909, 1911) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Home Runs

Honus Wagner 0
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in RBIs

Honus Wagner 5 (1901-1902, 1908-1909, 1912) StarStarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Hits

Honus Wagner 2 (1908, 1910) StarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Stolen Bases

Honus Wagner 5 (1901-1902, 1904, 1907-1908) StarStarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 4 (1910, 1919, 1923-1924) StarStarStarStar

League Leader in Total Bases

Honus Wagner 6 (1900, 1904, 1906-1909) StarStarStarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Doubles

Honus Wagner 7 (1900, 1902, 1904, 1906-1909) StarStarStarStarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Triples

Honus Wagner 3 (1900, 1903, 1908) StarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Runs

Honus Wagner 2 (1902, 1906) StarStar
Eddie Collins 3 (1912-1914) StarStarStar

League Leader in On-Base Percentage

Honus Wagner 4 (1904, 1907-1909) StarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Slugging Percentage

Honus Wagner 6 (1900, 1902, 1904, 1907-1909) StarStarStarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

Hitting

Games (G)

Honus Wagner 2,794
Eddie Collins 2,826

Plate Appearances (PA)

Honus Wagner 11,749
Eddie Collins 12,046

At Bats (AB)

Honus Wagner 10,439
Eddie Collins 9,949

Batting Average (BA)

Honus Wagner 0.328
Eddie Collins 0.333

Hits (H)

Honus Wagner 3,420
Eddie Collins 3,315

Runs (R)

Honus Wagner 1,739
Eddie Collins 1,821

Home Runs (HR)

Honus Wagner 101
Eddie Collins 47

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Honus Wagner 1,732
Eddie Collins 1,300

Doubles (2B)

Honus Wagner 643
Eddie Collins 438

Triples (3B)

Honus Wagner 252
Eddie Collins 187

Walks (BB)

Honus Wagner 963
Eddie Collins 1,499

Strikeouts (SO)

Honus Wagner 735
Eddie Collins 468

Stolen Bases (SB)

Honus Wagner 723
Eddie Collins 741

Caught Stealing (CS)

Honus Wagner 26
Eddie Collins 195

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Honus Wagner 0.391
Eddie Collins 0.424

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Honus Wagner 0.467
Eddie Collins 0.429

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Honus Wagner 0.858
Eddie Collins 0.853

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Honus Wagner 125
Eddie Collins 77

Total Bases (TB)

Honus Wagner 4,870
Eddie Collins 4,268

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Honus Wagner 996
Eddie Collins 672

Batting Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Honus Wagner 0.346
Eddie Collins 0.346

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Honus Wagner 0.139
Eddie Collins 0.096

Secondary Average (SECA)

Honus Wagner 0.298
Eddie Collins 0.301

Total Average (TotA)

Honus Wagner 0.945
Eddie Collins 0.936

Power-Speed (PwrSpd)

Honus Wagner 177.2
Eddie Collins 88.4

Walk Percentage (BB%)

Honus Wagner 8.2%
Eddie Collins 12.4%

Strikeouts Percentage (SO%)

Honus Wagner 6.3%
Eddie Collins 3.9%

Ball In-Play Percentage (IP%)

Honus Wagner 82%
Eddie Collins 78%

At Bats per Home Run (ABPHR)

Honus Wagner 103.4
Eddie Collins 211.7

Wins Above Replacement (WAR)

Honus Wagner 130.9
Eddie Collins 124

Playoff Hitting

Games (G)

Honus Wagner 15
Eddie Collins 34

Plate Appearances (PA)

Honus Wagner 62
Eddie Collins 147

At Bats (AB)

Honus Wagner 51
Eddie Collins 128

Batting Average (BA)

Honus Wagner .275
Eddie Collins .328

Hits (H)

Honus Wagner 14
Eddie Collins 42

Runs (R)

Honus Wagner 6
Eddie Collins 20

Home Runs (HR)

Honus Wagner 0
Eddie Collins 0

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Honus Wagner 9
Eddie Collins 11

Doubles (2B)

Honus Wagner 3
Eddie Collins 7

Triples (3B)

Honus Wagner 1
Eddie Collins 2

Walks (BB)

Honus Wagner 7
Eddie Collins 10

Strikeouts (SO)

Honus Wagner 6
Eddie Collins 11

Stolen Bases (SB)

Honus Wagner 9
Eddie Collins 14

Caught Stealing (CS)

Honus Wagner 0
Eddie Collins 0

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Honus Wagner 3
Eddie Collins 1

Total Bases (TB)

Honus Wagner 19
Eddie Collins 53

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Honus Wagner .393
Eddie Collins .381

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Honus Wagner .373
Eddie Collins .414

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Honus Wagner 0.766
Eddie Collins 0.795

Bating Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Honus Wagner .311
Eddie Collins .359

Strikeouts Percentage (SO%)

Honus Wagner 9.7%
Eddie Collins 7.5%

Walk Percentage (BBP)

Honus Wagner 11.3%
Eddie Collins 6.8%

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Honus Wagner .098
Eddie Collins .086

Secondary Average (SECA)

Honus Wagner .412
Eddie Collins .273

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Honus Wagner 4
Eddie Collins 9

Best Hitting

Games (G)

Honus Wagner 156 (1915)
Eddie Collins 156 (1917)

At Bats (AB)

Honus Wagner 588 (1898)
Eddie Collins 602 (1920)

Plate Appearances (PA)

Honus Wagner 641 (1908)
Eddie Collins 703 (1920)

Batting Average (BA)

Honus Wagner 0.381 (1900)
Eddie Collins 0.500 (1930)

Hits (H)

Honus Wagner 201 (1908)
Eddie Collins 224 (1920)

Runs (R)

Honus Wagner 114 (1905)
Eddie Collins 137 (1912)

Home Runs (HR)

Honus Wagner 10 (1908)
Eddie Collins 6 (1924)

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Honus Wagner 126 (1901)
Eddie Collins 86 (1924)

Doubles (2B)

Honus Wagner 45 (1900)
Eddie Collins 38 (1920)

Triples (3B)

Honus Wagner 22 (1900)
Eddie Collins 17 (1916)

Walks (BB)

Honus Wagner 67 (1911)
Eddie Collins 119 (1915)

Strikeouts (SO)

Honus Wagner 14 (1897)
Eddie Collins 0 (1930)

Stolen Bases (SB)

Honus Wagner 61 (1907)
Eddie Collins 81 (1910)

Caught Stealing (CS)

Honus Wagner 0 (1917)
Eddie Collins 0 (1930)

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Honus Wagner 14 (1902)
Eddie Collins 15 (1911)

Total Bases (TB)

Honus Wagner 308 (1908)
Eddie Collins 297 (1920)

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Honus Wagner 0.434 (1900)
Eddie Collins 0.500 (1930)

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Honus Wagner 0.573 (1900)
Eddie Collins 0.500 (1930)

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Honus Wagner 1.007 (1900)
Eddie Collins 1.000 (1930)

Wins Above Replacement (WAR)

Honus Wagner 11.5 (1908)
Eddie Collins 10.5 (1910)

Runs Created (RC)

Honus Wagner 129 (1900)
Eddie Collins 131 (1920)

Bating Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Honus Wagner 0.395 (1905)
Eddie Collins 0.500 (1930)

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Honus Wagner 0.192 (1900)
Eddie Collins 0.121 (1920)

Secondary Average (SECA)

Honus Wagner 0.400 (1904)
Eddie Collins 0.371 (1913)

Strikeouts Percentage (KP)

Honus Wagner 2.9% (1900)
Eddie Collins 0.0% (1930)

Walk Percentage (BBP)

Honus Wagner 12.0% (1911)
Eddie Collins 22.2% (1929)

At Bats per Home Run (ABPHR)

Honus Wagner 0.0 (1917)
Eddie Collins 0.0 (1930)

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Honus Wagner 71 (1900)
Eddie Collins 54 (1920)

Sacrifice Flies (SF)

Honus Wagner 0 (1917)
Eddie Collins 0 (1930)

Seasons

Check/Uncheck

Honus Wagner

Check/Uncheck

Eddie Collins

 

Info

Teams

Honus Wagner Louisville Colonels (1897–1899), Pittsburg / Pittsburgh Pirates (1900–1917)
Eddie Collins Philadelphia Athletics (1906-1914, 1927-1930), Chicago White Sox (1915-1926)

Position

Honus Wagner Shortstop
Eddie Collins Second Baseman

Height

Honus Wagner 5'11"
Eddie Collins 5'9"

Weight

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Bats

Honus Wagner Right
Eddie Collins Left

Throws

Honus Wagner Right
Eddie Collins Right

World Series And Playoff Appearances

World Series

Honus Wagner 1 (1909)
Eddie Collins 6 (1910-1911, 1913, 1917, 1929-1930)

World Series Appearances

Honus Wagner 2 (1903, 1909)
Eddie Collins 8 (1910-1911, 1913-1914, 1917, 1919, 1929-1930)

Playoff Appearances

Honus Wagner 2 (1903, 1909)
Eddie Collins 8 (1910-1911, 1913-1914, 1917, 1919, 1929-1930)

Awards And Honors

Hall of Fame

Honus Wagner Yes 95.13% in 1936
Eddie Collins Yes 77.74% in 1939

Number Retired

Honus Wagner Yes
Eddie Collins No

MVP

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

League Batting Champion

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

League Leader in Home Runs

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

League Leader in RBIs

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

League Leader in Hits

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

League Leader in Stolen Bases

Honus Wagner 5 (1901-1902, 1904, 1907-1908)
Eddie Collins 4 (1910, 1919, 1923-1924)

League Leader in Total Bases

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

League Leader in Doubles

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

League Leader in Triples

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

League Leader in Runs

Honus Wagner 2 (1902, 1906)
Eddie Collins 3 (1912-1914)

League Leader in On-Base Percentage

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

League Leader in Slugging Percentage

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Hitting

Games (G)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Plate Appearances (PA)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

At Bats (AB)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Batting Average (BA)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Hits (H)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Runs (R)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Home Runs (HR)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Doubles (2B)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Triples (3B)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Walks (BB)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Strikeouts (SO)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Stolen Bases (SB)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Caught Stealing (CS)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Total Bases (TB)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Batting Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Secondary Average (SECA)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Total Average (TotA)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Power-Speed (PwrSpd)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Walk Percentage (BB%)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Strikeouts Percentage (SO%)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Ball In-Play Percentage (IP%)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

At Bats per Home Run (ABPHR)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Wins Above Replacement (WAR)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Playoff Hitting

Games (G)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Plate Appearances (PA)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

At Bats (AB)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Batting Average (BA)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Hits (H)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Runs (R)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Home Runs (HR)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Doubles (2B)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Triples (3B)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Walks (BB)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Strikeouts (SO)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Stolen Bases (SB)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Caught Stealing (CS)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Total Bases (TB)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Bating Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Strikeouts Percentage (SO%)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Walk Percentage (BBP)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Secondary Average (SECA)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Honus Wagner Eddie Collins

Who do you think is the better player?

Who do you think is the better player?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...