MLB Comparisons

MLB Player Comparisons

Johnny Bench vs Carlton Fisk Comparison

by Leave a Comment

Seasons

Check/Uncheck

Johnny Bench

Check/Uncheck

Carlton Fisk

 

Info

Teams

Johnny Bench Cincinnati Reds (1967-1983)
Carlton Fisk Boston Red Sox (1969, 1971-1980), Chicago White Sox (1981-1993)

Position

Johnny Bench Catcher, Third Baseman, First Baseman
Carlton Fisk Catcher

Height

Johnny Bench 6'1"
Carlton Fisk 6'3"

Weight

Johnny Bench 197
Carlton Fisk 200

Bats

Johnny Bench Right
Carlton Fisk Right

Throws

Johnny Bench Right
Carlton Fisk Right

Drafted/Signed

Johnny Bench By the Reds in the 2nd Round (36th Overall) in the 1965 Draft
Carlton Fisk By the Red Sox in the 1st Round (4th Overall) in the 1967 Draft

World Series And Playoff Appearances

World Series

Johnny Bench 2 (1975-1976) StarStar
Carlton Fisk 0

World Series Appearances

Johnny Bench 4 (1970, 1972, 1975-1976) StarStarStarStar
Carlton Fisk 1 (1975) Star

Playoff Appearances

Johnny Bench 6 (1970, 1972-1973, 1975-1976, 1979) StarStarStarStarStarStar
Carlton Fisk 2 (1975, 1983) StarStar

World Series MVP

Johnny Bench 1 (1976) Star
Carlton Fisk 0

Awards And Honors

Hall of Fame

Johnny Bench Yes 96.42% in 1989
Carlton Fisk Yes 79.6% in 2000

Number Retired

Johnny Bench Yes Reds #5
Carlton Fisk Yes Red Sox #27 and White Sox #72

MVP

Johnny Bench 2 (1970, 1972) StarStar
Carlton Fisk 0

Gold Gloves

Johnny Bench 10 (1968–1977) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar
Carlton Fisk 1 (1972) Star

Rookie of the Year

Johnny Bench Yes (1968)
Carlton Fisk Yes (1972)

All-Star Games

Johnny Bench 14 (1968–1980, 1983) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar
Carlton Fisk 11 (1972-1974, 1976-1978, 1980-1982, 1985, 1991) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar

League Batting Champion

Johnny Bench 0
Carlton Fisk 0

League Leader in Home Runs

Johnny Bench 2 (1970, 1972) StarStar
Carlton Fisk 0

League Leader in RBIs

Johnny Bench 3 (1970, 1972, 1974) StarStarStar
Carlton Fisk 0

League Leader in Hits

Johnny Bench 0
Carlton Fisk 0

League Leader in Total Bases

Johnny Bench 1 (1974) Star
Carlton Fisk 0

League Leader in Doubles

Johnny Bench 0
Carlton Fisk 0

League Leader in Triples

Johnny Bench 0
Carlton Fisk 1 (1972) Star

League Leader in Runs

Johnny Bench 0
Carlton Fisk 0

League Leader in On-Base Percentage

Johnny Bench 0
Carlton Fisk 0

League Leader in Slugging Percentage

Johnny Bench 0
Carlton Fisk 0

Hitting

Games (G)

Johnny Bench 2,158
Carlton Fisk 2,499

Plate Appearances (PA)

Johnny Bench 8,674
Carlton Fisk 9,853

At Bats (AB)

Johnny Bench 7,658
Carlton Fisk 8,756

Batting Average (BA)

Johnny Bench 0.267
Carlton Fisk 0.269

Hits (H)

Johnny Bench 2,048
Carlton Fisk 2,356

Runs (R)

Johnny Bench 1,091
Carlton Fisk 1,276

Home Runs (HR)

Johnny Bench 389
Carlton Fisk 376

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Johnny Bench 1,376
Carlton Fisk 1,330

Doubles (2B)

Johnny Bench 381
Carlton Fisk 421

Triples (3B)

Johnny Bench 24
Carlton Fisk 47

Walks (BB)

Johnny Bench 891
Carlton Fisk 849

Strikeouts (SO)

Johnny Bench 1,278
Carlton Fisk 1,386

Stolen Bases (SB)

Johnny Bench 68
Carlton Fisk 128

Caught Stealing (CS)

Johnny Bench 43
Carlton Fisk 58

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Johnny Bench 0.342
Carlton Fisk 0.341

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Johnny Bench 0.476
Carlton Fisk 0.457

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Johnny Bench 0.817
Carlton Fisk 0.797

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Johnny Bench 19
Carlton Fisk 143

Total Bases (TB)

Johnny Bench 3,644
Carlton Fisk 3,999

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Johnny Bench 794
Carlton Fisk 844

Batting Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Johnny Bench 0.273
Carlton Fisk 0.280

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Johnny Bench 0.208
Carlton Fisk 0.188

Secondary Average (SECA)

Johnny Bench 0.328
Carlton Fisk 0.293

Total Average (TotA)

Johnny Bench 0.782
Carlton Fisk 0.760

Power-Speed (PwrSpd)

Johnny Bench 115.8
Carlton Fisk 191.0

Walk Percentage (BB%)

Johnny Bench 10.3%
Carlton Fisk 8.6%

Strikeouts Percentage (SO%)

Johnny Bench 14.7%
Carlton Fisk 14.1%

Ball In-Play Percentage (IP%)

Johnny Bench 70%
Carlton Fisk 72%

At Bats per Home Run (ABPHR)

Johnny Bench 19.7
Carlton Fisk 23.3

Wins Above Replacement (WAR)

Johnny Bench 74.9
Carlton Fisk 69.3

Fielding

Games (G)

Johnny Bench 2,193
Carlton Fisk 2,298

Games Started (GS)

Johnny Bench 2,003
Carlton Fisk 2,157

Innings (Inn)

Johnny Bench 17,713.2
Carlton Fisk 19,025.2

Fielding Percentage (FLD%)

Johnny Bench 0.987%
Carlton Fisk 0.987%

Errors (E)

Johnny Bench 151
Carlton Fisk 165

Chances (CH)

Johnny Bench 11,811
Carlton Fisk 12,852

Putouts (PO)

Johnny Bench 10,469
Carlton Fisk 11,612

Assists (A)

Johnny Bench 1,191
Carlton Fisk 1,075

Double Play (DP)

Johnny Bench 238
Carlton Fisk 167

Passed Balls (PB)

Johnny Bench 94
Carlton Fisk 78

Wild Pitches (WP)

Johnny Bench 446
Carlton Fisk 289

Stolen Bases (SB)

Johnny Bench 610
Carlton Fisk 778

Caught Stealing (CS)

Johnny Bench 469
Carlton Fisk 414

Caught Stealing Percentage (CS%)

Johnny Bench 43%
Carlton Fisk 35%

Range Factor per Game (RF/G)

Johnny Bench 5.32
Carlton Fisk 5.52

Range Factor per Inning (RF/9)

Johnny Bench 5.93
Carlton Fisk 6.00

Playoff Hitting

Games (G)

Johnny Bench 45
Carlton Fisk 14

Plate Appearances (PA)

Johnny Bench 188
Carlton Fisk 62

At Bats (AB)

Johnny Bench 169
Carlton Fisk 54

Batting Average (BA)

Johnny Bench .266
Carlton Fisk .259

Hits (H)

Johnny Bench 45
Carlton Fisk 14

Runs (R)

Johnny Bench 27
Carlton Fisk 9

Home Runs (HR)

Johnny Bench 10
Carlton Fisk 2

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Johnny Bench 20
Carlton Fisk 6

Doubles (2B)

Johnny Bench 8
Carlton Fisk 2

Triples (3B)

Johnny Bench 3
Carlton Fisk 0

Walks (BB)

Johnny Bench 18
Carlton Fisk 8

Strikeouts (SO)

Johnny Bench 29
Carlton Fisk 12

Stolen Bases (SB)

Johnny Bench 6
Carlton Fisk 1

Caught Stealing (CS)

Johnny Bench 1
Carlton Fisk 0

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Johnny Bench 0
Carlton Fisk 0

Total Bases (TB)

Johnny Bench 89
Carlton Fisk 22

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Johnny Bench .335
Carlton Fisk .355

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Johnny Bench .527
Carlton Fisk .407

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Johnny Bench 0.862
Carlton Fisk 0.762

Bating Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Johnny Bench .267
Carlton Fisk .300

Strikeouts Percentage (SO%)

Johnny Bench 15.4%
Carlton Fisk 19.4%

Walk Percentage (BBP)

Johnny Bench 9.6%
Carlton Fisk 12.9%

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Johnny Bench .260
Carlton Fisk .148

Secondary Average (SECA)

Johnny Bench .396
Carlton Fisk .315

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Johnny Bench 21
Carlton Fisk 4

Best Hitting

Games (G)

Johnny Bench 160 (1974)
Carlton Fisk 157 (1978)

At Bats (AB)

Johnny Bench 621 (1974)
Carlton Fisk 571 (1978)

Plate Appearances (PA)

Johnny Bench 708 (1974)
Carlton Fisk 658 (1978)

Batting Average (BA)

Johnny Bench 0.309 (1981)
Carlton Fisk 0.331 (1975)

Hits (H)

Johnny Bench 177 (1970)
Carlton Fisk 169 (1977)

Runs (R)

Johnny Bench 108 (1974)
Carlton Fisk 106 (1977)

Home Runs (HR)

Johnny Bench 45 (1970)
Carlton Fisk 37 (1985)

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Johnny Bench 148 (1970)
Carlton Fisk 107 (1985)

Doubles (2B)

Johnny Bench 40 (1968)
Carlton Fisk 39 (1978)

Triples (3B)

Johnny Bench 4 (1970)
Carlton Fisk 9 (1972)

Walks (BB)

Johnny Bench 100 (1972)
Carlton Fisk 75 (1977)

Strikeouts (SO)

Johnny Bench 19 (1967)
Carlton Fisk 2 (1969)

Stolen Bases (SB)

Johnny Bench 13 (1976)
Carlton Fisk 17 (1985)

Caught Stealing (CS)

Johnny Bench 0 (1975)
Carlton Fisk 0 (1992)

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Johnny Bench 4 (1969)
Carlton Fisk 17 (1985)

Total Bases (TB)

Johnny Bench 355 (1970)
Carlton Fisk 279 (1977)

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Johnny Bench 0.379 (1972)
Carlton Fisk 0.402 (1977)

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Johnny Bench 0.587 (1970)
Carlton Fisk 0.551 (1974)

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Johnny Bench 0.932 (1970)
Carlton Fisk 0.934 (1974)

Wins Above Replacement (WAR)

Johnny Bench 8.6 (1972)
Carlton Fisk 7.3 (1973)

Bating Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Johnny Bench 0.315 (1981)
Carlton Fisk 0.361 (1971)

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Johnny Bench 0.294 (1970)
Carlton Fisk 0.265 (1988)

Secondary Average (SECA)

Johnny Bench 0.457 (1972)
Carlton Fisk 0.411 (1988)

Strikeouts Percentage (KP)

Johnny Bench 10.7% (1981)
Carlton Fisk 9.4% (1981)

Walk Percentage (BBP)

Johnny Bench 15.3% (1972)
Carlton Fisk 12.4% (1988)

At Bats per Home Run (ABPHR)

Johnny Bench 13.4 (1972)
Carlton Fisk 0.0 (1969)

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Johnny Bench 84 (1970)
Carlton Fisk 64 (1978)

Sacrifice Flies (SF)

Johnny Bench 12 (1972)
Carlton Fisk 10 (1977)

Best Fielding

Games (G)

Johnny Bench 178 (1974)
Carlton Fisk 155 (1978)

Games Started (GS)

Johnny Bench 159 (1974)
Carlton Fisk 151 (1978)

Innings (Inn)

Johnny Bench 1409.1 (1974)
Carlton Fisk 1361.20 (1978)

Fielding Percentage (FLDP)

Johnny Bench 0.995% (1967)
Carlton Fisk 1.000% (1993)

Errors (E)

Johnny Bench 1 (1967)
Carlton Fisk 0 (1993)

Chances (CH)

Johnny Bench 1053 (1968)
Carlton Fisk 933 (1972)

Putouts (PO)

Johnny Bench 942 (1968)
Carlton Fisk 846 (1972)

Assists (A)

Johnny Bench 159 (1982)
Carlton Fisk 90 (1978)

Double Play (DP)

Johnny Bench 35 (1981)
Carlton Fisk 22 (1987)

Range Factor per Game (RF/G)

Johnny Bench 8.96 (1981)
Carlton Fisk 7.01 (1972)

Range Factor per Inning (RF/9)

Johnny Bench 9.49 (1981)
Carlton Fisk 7.25 (1985)

Seasons

Check/Uncheck

Johnny Bench

Check/Uncheck

Carlton Fisk

 

Info

Teams

Johnny Bench Cincinnati Reds (1967-1983)
Carlton Fisk Boston Red Sox (1969, 1971-1980), Chicago White Sox (1981-1993)

Position

Johnny Bench Catcher, Third Baseman, First Baseman
Carlton Fisk Catcher

Height

Johnny Bench 6'1"
Carlton Fisk 6'3"

Weight

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Bats

Johnny Bench Right
Carlton Fisk Right

Throws

Johnny Bench Right
Carlton Fisk Right

Drafted/Signed

Johnny Bench By the Reds in the 2nd Round (36th Overall) in the 1965 Draft
Carlton Fisk By the Red Sox in the 1st Round (4th Overall) in the 1967 Draft

World Series And Playoff Appearances

World Series

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

World Series Appearances

Johnny Bench 4 (1970, 1972, 1975-1976)
Carlton Fisk 1 (1975)

Playoff Appearances

Johnny Bench 6 (1970, 1972-1973, 1975-1976, 1979)
Carlton Fisk 2 (1975, 1983)

World Series MVP

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Awards And Honors

Hall of Fame

Johnny Bench Yes 96.42% in 1989
Carlton Fisk Yes 79.6% in 2000

Number Retired

Johnny Bench Yes Reds #5
Carlton Fisk Yes Red Sox #27 and White Sox #72

MVP

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Gold Gloves

Johnny Bench 10 (1968–1977)
Carlton Fisk 1 (1972)

Rookie of the Year

Johnny Bench Yes (1968)
Carlton Fisk Yes (1972)

All-Star Games

Johnny Bench 14 (1968–1980, 1983)
Carlton Fisk 11 (1972-1974, 1976-1978, 1980-1982, 1985, 1991)

League Batting Champion

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

League Leader in Home Runs

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

League Leader in RBIs

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

League Leader in Hits

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

League Leader in Total Bases

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

League Leader in Doubles

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

League Leader in Triples

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

League Leader in Runs

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

League Leader in On-Base Percentage

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

League Leader in Slugging Percentage

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Hitting

Games (G)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Plate Appearances (PA)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

At Bats (AB)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Batting Average (BA)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Hits (H)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Runs (R)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Home Runs (HR)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Doubles (2B)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Triples (3B)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Walks (BB)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Strikeouts (SO)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Stolen Bases (SB)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Caught Stealing (CS)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Total Bases (TB)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Batting Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Secondary Average (SECA)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Total Average (TotA)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Power-Speed (PwrSpd)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Walk Percentage (BB%)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Strikeouts Percentage (SO%)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Ball In-Play Percentage (IP%)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

At Bats per Home Run (ABPHR)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Wins Above Replacement (WAR)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Fielding

Games (G)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Games Started (GS)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Innings (Inn)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Fielding Percentage (FLD%)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Errors (E)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Chances (CH)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Putouts (PO)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Assists (A)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Double Play (DP)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Passed Balls (PB)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Wild Pitches (WP)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Stolen Bases (SB)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Caught Stealing (CS)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Caught Stealing Percentage (CS%)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Range Factor per Game (RF/G)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Range Factor per Inning (RF/9)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Playoff Hitting

Games (G)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Plate Appearances (PA)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

At Bats (AB)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Batting Average (BA)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Hits (H)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Runs (R)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Home Runs (HR)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Doubles (2B)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Triples (3B)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Walks (BB)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Strikeouts (SO)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Stolen Bases (SB)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Caught Stealing (CS)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Total Bases (TB)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Bating Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Strikeouts Percentage (SO%)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Walk Percentage (BBP)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Secondary Average (SECA)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Johnny Bench Carlton Fisk

Who do you think is the better player?

Who do you think is the better player?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...