MLB Comparisons

MLB Player Comparisons

Rogers Hornsby vs Eddie Collins Comparison

by Leave a Comment

Seasons

Check/Uncheck

Rogers Hornsby

Check/Uncheck

Eddie Collins

 

Info

Teams

Rogers Hornsby St. Louis Cardinals (1915-1926, 1933) New York Giants (1927) Boston Braves (1928), Chicago Cubs (1929-1932) St. Louis Browns (1933-1937)
Eddie Collins Philadelphia Athletics (1906-1914, 1927-1930), Chicago White Sox (1915-1926)

Position

Rogers Hornsby Second Baseman, Third Baseman, Shortstop
Eddie Collins Second Baseman

Height

Rogers Hornsby 5'11"
Eddie Collins 5'9"

Weight

Rogers Hornsby 175
Eddie Collins 175

Bats

Rogers Hornsby Right
Eddie Collins Left

Throws

Rogers Hornsby Right
Eddie Collins Right

World Series And Playoff Appearances

World Series

Rogers Hornsby 1 (1926) Star
Eddie Collins 6 (1910-1911, 1913, 1917, 1929-1930) StarStarStarStarStarStar

World Series Appearances

Rogers Hornsby 2 (1926, 1929) StarStar
Eddie Collins 8 (1910-1911, 1913-1914, 1917, 1919, 1929-1930) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar

Playoff Appearances

Rogers Hornsby 2 (1926, 1929) StarStar
Eddie Collins 8 (1910-1911, 1913-1914, 1917, 1919, 1929-1930) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar

Awards And Honors

Hall of Fame

Rogers Hornsby Yes 78.1% in 1942
Eddie Collins Yes 77.74% in 1939

Number Retired

Rogers Hornsby No
Eddie Collins No

MVP

Rogers Hornsby 2 (1925, 1929) StarStar
Eddie Collins 1 (1914) Star

League Batting Champion

Rogers Hornsby 7 (1920-1925, 1928) StarStarStarStarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Home Runs

Rogers Hornsby 2 (1922, 1925) StarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in RBIs

Rogers Hornsby 4 (1920-1922, 1925) StarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Hits

Rogers Hornsby 4 (1920-1922, 1924) StarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Stolen Bases

Rogers Hornsby 0
Eddie Collins 4 (1910, 1919, 1923-1924) StarStarStarStar

League Leader in Total Bases

Rogers Hornsby 7 (1917, 1920-1922, 1924-1925, 1929) StarStarStarStarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Doubles

Rogers Hornsby 4 (1920-1922, 1924) StarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Triples

Rogers Hornsby 2 (1917, 1921) StarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Runs

Rogers Hornsby 5 (1921-1922, 1924, 1927, 1929) StarStarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 3 (1912-1914) StarStarStar

League Leader in On-Base Percentage

Rogers Hornsby 9 (1920-1925, 1927-1928, 1931) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

League Leader in Slugging Percentage

Rogers Hornsby 9 (1917, 1920-1925, 1928-1929) StarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar
Eddie Collins 0

Hitting

Games (G)

Rogers Hornsby 2,259
Eddie Collins 2,826

Plate Appearances (PA)

Rogers Hornsby 9,480
Eddie Collins 12,046

At Bats (AB)

Rogers Hornsby 8,173
Eddie Collins 9,949

Batting Average (BA)

Rogers Hornsby 0.358
Eddie Collins 0.333

Hits (H)

Rogers Hornsby 2,930
Eddie Collins 3,315

Runs (R)

Rogers Hornsby 1,579
Eddie Collins 1,821

Home Runs (HR)

Rogers Hornsby 301
Eddie Collins 47

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Rogers Hornsby 1,584
Eddie Collins 1,300

Doubles (2B)

Rogers Hornsby 541
Eddie Collins 438

Triples (3B)

Rogers Hornsby 169
Eddie Collins 187

Walks (BB)

Rogers Hornsby 1,038
Eddie Collins 1,499

Strikeouts (SO)

Rogers Hornsby 679
Eddie Collins 468

Stolen Bases (SB)

Rogers Hornsby 135
Eddie Collins 741

Caught Stealing (CS)

Rogers Hornsby 64
Eddie Collins 195

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Rogers Hornsby 0.434
Eddie Collins 0.424

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Rogers Hornsby 0.577
Eddie Collins 0.429

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Rogers Hornsby 1.010
Eddie Collins 0.853

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Rogers Hornsby 48
Eddie Collins 77

Total Bases (TB)

Rogers Hornsby 4,712
Eddie Collins 4,268

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Rogers Hornsby 1,011
Eddie Collins 672

Batting Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Rogers Hornsby 0.365
Eddie Collins 0.346

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Rogers Hornsby 0.218
Eddie Collins 0.096

Secondary Average (SECA)

Rogers Hornsby 0.354
Eddie Collins 0.301

Power-Speed (PwrSpd)

Rogers Hornsby 186.4
Eddie Collins 88.4

Walk Percentage (BB%)

Rogers Hornsby 10.9%
Eddie Collins 12.4%

Strikeouts Percentage (SO%)

Rogers Hornsby 7.2%
Eddie Collins 3.9%

Ball In-Play Percentage (IP%)

Rogers Hornsby 76%
Eddie Collins 78%

At Bats per Home Run (ABPHR)

Rogers Hornsby 27.2
Eddie Collins 211.7

Wins Above Replacement (WAR)

Rogers Hornsby 126.9
Eddie Collins 124

Fielding

Games (G)

Rogers Hornsby 2,164
Eddie Collins 2,701

Innings (Inn)

Rogers Hornsby 18,922
Eddie Collins 23,943

Fielding Percentage (FLD%)

Rogers Hornsby 0.958%
Eddie Collins 0.969%

Errors (E)

Rogers Hornsby 500
Eddie Collins 452

Chances (CH)

Rogers Hornsby 11,837
Eddie Collins 14,789

Putouts (PO)

Rogers Hornsby 4,495
Eddie Collins 6,621

Assists (A)

Rogers Hornsby 6,842
Eddie Collins 7,716

Double Play (DP)

Rogers Hornsby 1,132
Eddie Collins 1,247

Range Factor per Game (RF/G)

Rogers Hornsby 5.24
Eddie Collins 5.31

Range Factor per Inning (RF/9)

Rogers Hornsby 5.39
Eddie Collins 5.39

Playoff Hitting

Games (G)

Rogers Hornsby 12
Eddie Collins 34

Plate Appearances (PA)

Rogers Hornsby 53
Eddie Collins 147

At Bats (AB)

Rogers Hornsby 49
Eddie Collins 128

Batting Average (BA)

Rogers Hornsby .245
Eddie Collins .328

Hits (H)

Rogers Hornsby 12
Eddie Collins 42

Runs (R)

Rogers Hornsby 6
Eddie Collins 20

Home Runs (HR)

Rogers Hornsby 0
Eddie Collins 0

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Rogers Hornsby 5
Eddie Collins 11

Doubles (2B)

Rogers Hornsby 2
Eddie Collins 7

Triples (3B)

Rogers Hornsby 1
Eddie Collins 2

Walks (BB)

Rogers Hornsby 3
Eddie Collins 10

Strikeouts (SO)

Rogers Hornsby 10
Eddie Collins 11

Stolen Bases (SB)

Rogers Hornsby 1
Eddie Collins 14

Caught Stealing (CS)

Rogers Hornsby 0
Eddie Collins 0

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Rogers Hornsby 0
Eddie Collins 1

Total Bases (TB)

Rogers Hornsby 16
Eddie Collins 53

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Rogers Hornsby .288
Eddie Collins .381

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Rogers Hornsby .327
Eddie Collins .414

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Rogers Hornsby 0.615
Eddie Collins 0.795

Bating Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Rogers Hornsby .308
Eddie Collins .359

Strikeouts Percentage (SO%)

Rogers Hornsby 18.9%
Eddie Collins 7.5%

Walk Percentage (BBP)

Rogers Hornsby 5.7%
Eddie Collins 6.8%

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Rogers Hornsby .082
Eddie Collins .086

Secondary Average (SECA)

Rogers Hornsby .163
Eddie Collins .273

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Rogers Hornsby 3
Eddie Collins 9

Best Hitting

Games (G)

Rogers Hornsby 156 (1929)
Eddie Collins 156 (1917)

At Bats (AB)

Rogers Hornsby 623 (1922)
Eddie Collins 602 (1920)

Plate Appearances (PA)

Rogers Hornsby 712 (1929)
Eddie Collins 703 (1920)

Batting Average (BA)

Rogers Hornsby 0.424 (1924)
Eddie Collins 0.500 (1930)

Hits (H)

Rogers Hornsby 250 (1922)
Eddie Collins 224 (1920)

Runs (R)

Rogers Hornsby 156 (1929)
Eddie Collins 137 (1912)

Home Runs (HR)

Rogers Hornsby 42 (1922)
Eddie Collins 6 (1924)

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Rogers Hornsby 152 (1922)
Eddie Collins 86 (1924)

Doubles (2B)

Rogers Hornsby 47 (1929)
Eddie Collins 38 (1920)

Triples (3B)

Rogers Hornsby 20 (1920)
Eddie Collins 17 (1916)

Walks (BB)

Rogers Hornsby 107 (1928)
Eddie Collins 119 (1915)

Strikeouts (SO)

Rogers Hornsby 0 (1936)
Eddie Collins 0 (1930)

Stolen Bases (SB)

Rogers Hornsby 17 (1922)
Eddie Collins 81 (1910)

Caught Stealing (CS)

Rogers Hornsby 0 (1937)
Eddie Collins 0 (1930)

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Rogers Hornsby 7 (1921)
Eddie Collins 15 (1911)

Total Bases (TB)

Rogers Hornsby 450 (1922)
Eddie Collins 297 (1920)

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Rogers Hornsby 0.507 (1924)
Eddie Collins 0.500 (1930)

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Rogers Hornsby 0.756 (1925)
Eddie Collins 0.500 (1930)

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Rogers Hornsby 1.245 (1925)
Eddie Collins 1.000 (1930)

Wins Above Replacement (WAR)

Rogers Hornsby 12.1 (1924)
Eddie Collins 10.5 (1910)

Runs Created (RC)

Rogers Hornsby 202 (1922)
Eddie Collins 131 (1920)

Bating Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Rogers Hornsby 0.422 (1924)
Eddie Collins 0.500 (1930)

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Rogers Hornsby 0.353 (1925)
Eddie Collins 0.121 (1920)

Secondary Average (SECA)

Rogers Hornsby 0.522 (1934)
Eddie Collins 0.371 (1913)

Strikeouts Percentage (KP)

Rogers Hornsby 0.0% (1936)
Eddie Collins 0.0% (1930)

Walk Percentage (BBP)

Rogers Hornsby 22.6% (1934)
Eddie Collins 22.2% (1929)

At Bats per Home Run (ABPHR)

Rogers Hornsby 0.0 (1936)
Eddie Collins 0.0 (1930)

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Rogers Hornsby 102 (1922)
Eddie Collins 54 (1920)

Sacrifice Flies (SF)

Rogers Hornsby 0 (1937)
Eddie Collins 0 (1930)

Best Fielding

Games (G)

Rogers Hornsby 156 (1929)
Eddie Collins 156 (1917)

Innings (Inn)

Rogers Hornsby 1388.0 (1929)
Eddie Collins 1417.0 (1917)

Fielding Percentage (FLDP)

Rogers Hornsby 1.000% (1936)
Eddie Collins 1.000% (1928)

Errors (E)

Rogers Hornsby 0 (1936)
Eddie Collins 0 (1928)

Chances (CH)

Rogers Hornsby 906 (1927)
Eddie Collins 943 (1920)

Putouts (PO)

Rogers Hornsby 398 (1922)
Eddie Collins 449 (1920)

Assists (A)

Rogers Hornsby 582 (1927)
Eddie Collins 487 (1915)

Double Play (DP)

Rogers Hornsby 106 (1929)
Eddie Collins 89 (1921)

Range Factor per Game (RF/G)

Rogers Hornsby 10.00 (1936)
Eddie Collins 6.13 (1921)

Range Factor per Inning (RF/9)

Rogers Hornsby 10.00 (1936)
Eddie Collins 6.29 (1921)

Seasons

Check/Uncheck

Rogers Hornsby

Check/Uncheck

Eddie Collins

 

Info

Teams

Rogers Hornsby St. Louis Cardinals (1915-1926, 1933) New York Giants (1927) Boston Braves (1928), Chicago Cubs (1929-1932) St. Louis Browns (1933-1937)
Eddie Collins Philadelphia Athletics (1906-1914, 1927-1930), Chicago White Sox (1915-1926)

Position

Rogers Hornsby Second Baseman, Third Baseman, Shortstop
Eddie Collins Second Baseman

Height

Rogers Hornsby 5'11"
Eddie Collins 5'9"

Weight

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Bats

Rogers Hornsby Right
Eddie Collins Left

Throws

Rogers Hornsby Right
Eddie Collins Right

World Series And Playoff Appearances

World Series

Rogers Hornsby 1 (1926)
Eddie Collins 6 (1910-1911, 1913, 1917, 1929-1930)

World Series Appearances

Rogers Hornsby 2 (1926, 1929)
Eddie Collins 8 (1910-1911, 1913-1914, 1917, 1919, 1929-1930)

Playoff Appearances

Rogers Hornsby 2 (1926, 1929)
Eddie Collins 8 (1910-1911, 1913-1914, 1917, 1919, 1929-1930)

Awards And Honors

Hall of Fame

Rogers Hornsby Yes 78.1% in 1942
Eddie Collins Yes 77.74% in 1939

Number Retired

Rogers Hornsby No
Eddie Collins No

MVP

Rogers Hornsby 2 (1925, 1929)
Eddie Collins 1 (1914)

League Batting Champion

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

League Leader in Home Runs

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

League Leader in RBIs

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

League Leader in Hits

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

League Leader in Stolen Bases

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

League Leader in Total Bases

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

League Leader in Doubles

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

League Leader in Triples

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

League Leader in Runs

Rogers Hornsby 5 (1921-1922, 1924, 1927, 1929)
Eddie Collins 3 (1912-1914)

League Leader in On-Base Percentage

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

League Leader in Slugging Percentage

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Hitting

Games (G)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Plate Appearances (PA)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

At Bats (AB)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Batting Average (BA)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Hits (H)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Runs (R)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Home Runs (HR)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Doubles (2B)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Triples (3B)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Walks (BB)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Strikeouts (SO)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Stolen Bases (SB)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Caught Stealing (CS)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Total Bases (TB)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Batting Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Secondary Average (SECA)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Power-Speed (PwrSpd)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Walk Percentage (BB%)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Strikeouts Percentage (SO%)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Ball In-Play Percentage (IP%)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

At Bats per Home Run (ABPHR)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Wins Above Replacement (WAR)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Fielding

Games (G)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Innings (Inn)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Fielding Percentage (FLD%)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Errors (E)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Chances (CH)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Putouts (PO)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Assists (A)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Double Play (DP)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Range Factor per Game (RF/G)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Range Factor per Inning (RF/9)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Playoff Hitting

Games (G)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Plate Appearances (PA)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

At Bats (AB)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Batting Average (BA)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Hits (H)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Runs (R)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Home Runs (HR)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Runs Batted In (RBI)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Doubles (2B)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Triples (3B)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Walks (BB)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Strikeouts (SO)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Stolen Bases (SB)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Caught Stealing (CS)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Hit by Pitch (HBP)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Total Bases (TB)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

On Base Percentage (OBP)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Slugging Percentage (SLG)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

On Base Percentage Plus Slugging Percentage (OPS)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Bating Average on Balls in Play (BABIP)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Strikeouts Percentage (SO%)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Walk Percentage (BBP)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Isolated Power (ISOP)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Secondary Average (SECA)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Extra Base Hit (XBH)

Rogers Hornsby Eddie Collins

Who do you think is the better player?

Who do you think is the better player?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...